Arney's Pepper Co. | Bridgeton, NJ
Bridgeton, New Jersey · Est. 2026

Arney's
Pepper
Co. Grown here. Made by hand.

A backyard operation taking quality seriously. 14 varieties, one flagship sauce, no shortcuts. If it's not right, it doesn't leave the farm.

Farm dog in the pepper rows
WHAT I GROW
Jalapeño
Habanero
Ghost Pepper
Hungarian Hot Wax
Cayenne
Caribbean Red
Jamaican Yelling Yellow
Hot Banana
Fresno
Serrano
Tabasco
Scotch Bonnet
Chiltepin
Carolina Reaper
Hand crafted· Bridgeton, NJ· Small batch· Water bath processed· No preservatives· Grown on site· Salem County· 14 varieties· Every batch documented· Hand crafted· Bridgeton, NJ· Small batch· Water bath processed· No preservatives· Grown on site· Salem County· 14 varieties· Every batch documented·
My story
Trial and
error.
Still learning.

It started small. Just jalapeños and habaneros. Two varieties, a patch of ground, and no idea what I was getting into. That first season taught me enough to want more. So I pushed. More varieties, more plants, more ambition. By 2026 I was growing 14 varieties across twelve acres in Bridgeton, New Jersey.

None of it came easy. Plants died. Pests invaded. Diseases spread through rows I'd spent weeks building up. There were nights I was out there at 10pm with a flashlight picking bugs off leaves by hand because I wasn't willing to lose what I'd put into it. I treated every plant like it mattered, because it did. You don't pour that much of yourself into something and walk away when it gets hard.

Then came the harvest. And then the sauce. The process was tedious and humbling and I made plenty of mistakes. First batch came out right. Second batch I overcomplicated it and lost what made the first one work. Third batch I came back to basics, tightened everything up, and landed on something I was finally proud of. That's what's in this bottle.

I'm still learning. Every batch teaches me something. But the commitment hasn't changed from day one. Grow it right, make it right, and never put something in a bottle I wouldn't be proud to hand to someone face to face.

The pepper garden at golden hour — Bridgeton, NJ
12 acres of farmland
in Salem County
14 pepper varieties
grown this season
100% grown on site
no outside sourcing
NJ cottage food certified
every batch on record
Cayenne pepper harvest — Arney's Pepper Co.
The sauce
Arney's Original hot sauce — pot and filled bottles
Arney's
Original
The one I locked in and stopped changing.

Pepper forward with a quick, clean burn that doesn't overstay its welcome. The base is red-ripe jalapeños picked at full maturity from my garden, which gives them a sweeter, more complex flavor than anything pulled green off a truck. On top of that I layer orange habanero and red scotch bonnet for that fruity, floral Caribbean heat that builds differently than a straight jalapeño sauce.

Garlic and white onion round it out. No filler. No sugar. No stabilizers. Shake it, pour it, taste exactly what went into it.

The heat lands medium-hot. Enough that you know it's there, not so much that it gets in the way of the food. The garlic gives it a savory depth that people keep coming back for. It's been described as having a tomato sauce quality. That's the garlic and onion doing their job in an acidic base.

What's in it
BaseRed jalapeño (home grown)
HeatOrange habanero + scotch bonnet
AromaticsGarlic · white onion
VinegarWhite distilled (5% acidity)
Heat levelMedium-hot
PreservativesNone
Size5 fl oz glass woozy bottle
Made inBridgeton, NJ
$14
Per 5 oz bottle · Local pickup or delivery in Bridgeton area
Order a bottle
How it's made
01
Grown here, not sourced

Every pepper starts as a seed on my farm in Bridgeton. I tend 14 varieties by hand through the whole season, from transplant in the spring to final harvest in the fall. I don't buy peppers from a distributor and call it artisan. If it didn't come out of my ground, it doesn't go in the bottle. Full stop.

02
Inspected by hand

Every single pepper is halved and checked before it goes in the pot. I work mildest to hottest, jalapeños first and superhots last, so nothing gets missed. Firm flesh, smells like pepper, zero soft spots and it's in. Anything that doesn't pass gets thrown out. One bad pod can compromise an entire batch and I'm not sending that to anyone.

03
Processed and documented

Every batch is simmered, blended, strained, and water bath processed for full shelf stability. I keep a complete production log for every batch. Ingredients, weights, dates, everything. Not because a regulation makes me, but because if you're buying something to put on your food you deserve to know it was done right by someone who takes it seriously.

Red jalapeños weighed and prepped for sauce — Arney's Pepper Co.
Place an order
Ready for a bottle?

Fill out the form and I'll get back to you within 24 hours to sort out pickup or local delivery.

Pickup available in Bridgeton, NJ
Local delivery for orders of 3+ bottles
$14 per 5 oz bottle
Payment arranged on pickup/delivery
🌶
Coming Soon

Online ordering is on its way. In the meantime, reach out directly at arneyspepperco@gmail.com.

The peppers
14 varieties.
All grown here.

Every pepper in the garden, with full heat data, flavor notes, and what makes each one worth growing.

Habanero, scotch bonnet and Caribbean red harvest tray
HEAT KEY
Mild
Medium
Hot
Very Hot
Extreme
Hot Banana
Capsicum annuum
500 – 3,500 SHU
Mild, tangy, slightly sweet with more heat than a standard banana pepper. The long yellow pods are excellent for pickling and stuffing. Bright and acidic with a gentle warmth that surprises people expecting zero heat.
MildTangy · Sweet · BrightPickling · Fresh · Stuffing
Hungarian Hot Wax
Capsicum annuum
1,000 – 15,000 SHU
Often mistaken for a banana pepper but significantly hotter. Tangy, slightly sweet flavor with waxy texture. One of the best pickling peppers in the garden. Medium heat that catches people off guard.
Mild-MediumTangy · Sweet · WaxyPickling · Stuffing · Fresh
Jalapeño
Capsicum annuum
2,500 – 8,000 SHU
The backbone of the flagship sauce. Red-ripe jalapeños develop a sweeter, more complex flavor than green ones. Thick flesh, grassy brightness, and a clean burn that hits fast and finishes clean.
Mild-MediumGrassy · Bright · CleanHot sauce · Salsa · Pickling
Fresno
Capsicum annuum
2,500 – 10,000 SHU
Looks like a jalapeño but develops a fruitier, smokier character at red maturity. Slightly more heat and a thinner wall make it better for sauce work. An underrated pepper that deserves more attention.
Mild-MediumFruity · Smoky · ComplexHot sauce · Salsa · Fresh
Serrano
Capsicum annuum
10,000 – 23,000 SHU
A jalapeño's hotter, sharper cousin. Bright, almost citrusy heat with a clean flavor that cuts through rich dishes. Thinner walls concentrate the heat more. The smaller the serrano, the hotter it tends to be.
Medium-HotSharp · Citrus · BrightSalsa · Pico de gallo · Fresh
Cayenne
Capsicum annuum
30,000 – 50,000 SHU
The classic hot pepper. Thin-fleshed with a fiery, slightly earthy heat that dries and powders beautifully. Sharp and forward with less fruity complexity than chinense varieties. Pure pepper fire.
HotEarthy · Sharp · FieryPowder · Drying · Hot sauce
Tabasco
Capsicum frutescens
30,000 – 50,000 SHU
The pepper behind the world's most recognized hot sauce. Thin-walled, juicy, intensely flavored with a bright acidic heat. Liquid-rich flesh makes it ideal for vinegar-based sauces. Sharp, distinctive, with a slightly smoky character at full ripeness.
HotAcidic · Juicy · SharpVinegar sauces · Fermented sauce
Chiltepin
Capsicum annuum var. glabriusculum
50,000 – 100,000 SHU
One of the oldest pepper varieties in North America, growing wild long before any cultivated varieties existed. Tiny round berries with a smoky, earthy heat that hits fast and fades quickly. Rare to grow intentionally and a point of pride in the garden.
HotSmoky · Earthy · WildTraditional cooking · Specialty sauces
Orange Habanero
Capsicum chinense
100,000 – 350,000 SHU
Classic tropical citrus aroma, immediately recognizable the moment it hits the pot. Intense, immediate heat with a floral sweetness that balances it. Gives the flagship sauce its Caribbean character and fruity depth.
Very HotTropical · Citrus · FloralHot sauce · Caribbean cuisine
Jamaican Yelling Yellow
Capsicum chinense
100,000 – 200,000 SHU
Fruity tropical character typical of the chinense family with a distinct yellow color and slightly less heat than a full habanero. Bright, sunny aroma. Earmarked for future sauce variations where the yellow color can take center stage.
Very HotTropical · Fruity · BrightHot sauce · Caribbean cuisine
Scotch Bonnet Red
Capsicum chinense
100,000 – 350,000 SHU
The most complex flavor in the garden. Tropical fruit notes, mango and pineapple, come before a powerful heat wave that builds and lingers. The floral, fruity flavor is what separates Caribbean hot sauce from everything else. A key ingredient in the flagship sauce.
Very HotMango · Pineapple · FloralCaribbean cuisine · Hot sauce
Caribbean Red Habanero
Capsicum chinense
300,000 – 445,000 SHU
Hotter than the standard orange habanero with a citrusy, slightly smoky character. A key ingredient in what makes the flagship sauce more than a one-note hot sauce. Adds depth that standard habaneros don't reach.
Very HotCitrus · Smoky · ComplexHot sauce · Caribbean cooking
Ghost Pepper
Capsicum chinense
855,000 – 1,041,427 SHU
Deceptively sweet upfront, then the heat arrives and keeps arriving. The ghost pepper's burn is delayed and prolonged. A subtle smokiness underlies the fruity initial flavor. Not in the flagship sauce. Reserved for future batches built around sustained heat.
ExtremeSmoky · Sweet · Delayed burnExtreme hot sauce
Carolina Reaper
Capsicum chinense
1,500,000 – 2,200,000 SHU
The world record holder. One plant in the garden, treated like the irreplaceable specimen it is. Fruity and almost sweet in the first half-second before the most intense heat any pepper can produce takes over. The burn is total, prolonged, and unlike anything else. Grown for the experience of growing something extraordinary.
World Record HolderFruity · Then Everything
"I grew these because I wanted to make a hot sauce I loved and was proud of, and that other people could love and appreciate."
Every variety in this garden played a part in getting the sauce right. From the mildest banana pepper to the Carolina Reaper. Most of them never went into the bottle, but growing them, tasting them, and understanding them is what made the one that did worth being proud of.